When starting an herb garden, one of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to grow herbs from seeds or buy young plants (seedlings or transplants) from a nursery. Both methods have their advantages and challenges, and the best choice depends on your time, budget, and gardening goals.

In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each approach, along with tips to help you succeed no matter which method you choose.

1. Growing Herbs from Seeds

Starting herbs from seeds is a cost-effective and rewarding option, but it requires patience and the right conditions for successful germination.

✅ Pros of Growing Herbs from Seeds:

✔ More Variety – Nurseries often stock only common herbs, but with seeds, you can grow unique or heirloom varieties.
✔ Inexpensive – A packet of seeds costs less than a single potted plant and can produce many herbs.
✔ Control Over Growth – Starting from seed ensures you grow organic or pesticide-free herbs if desired.

❌ Cons of Growing Herbs from Seeds:

✖ Takes Time – Many herbs take weeks to germinate and months to mature.
✖ Requires Attention – Seedlings need consistent moisture, warmth, and light to thrive.
✖ Not All Herbs Grow Easily from Seed – Some, like rosemary and lavender, have low germination rates.

🌱 Best Herbs to Start from Seeds:

✔ Basil – Fast-growing and easy to germinate.
✔ Cilantro (Coriander) – Grows quickly but bolts in heat.
✔ Dill – Grows best when direct-seeded.
✔ Chives – Slow-growing but worth the wait.
✔ Parsley – Takes time to germinate but grows well from seed.

Tips for Success with Herb Seeds:

🌡 Use a Seed-Starting Tray – Provides controlled conditions for germination.
☀ Provide Adequate Light – Place seedlings in a sunny spot or use grow lights.
💧 Keep Soil Moist but Not Soggy – Consistent moisture helps seeds sprout.
🕰 Be Patient – Some herbs take longer to germinate, so don’t give up too soon!

2. Buying Herb Plants (Transplants or Seedlings)

Purchasing young plants from a garden center or nursery allows you to skip the germination phase and enjoy fresh herbs sooner.

✅ Pros of Buying Herb Plants:

✔ Instant Gratification – No waiting for germination—plants are ready to grow.
✔ Higher Success Rate – More resilient than delicate seedlings.
✔ Great for Difficult-to-Grow Herbs – Some herbs, like rosemary and thyme, are easier to establish as transplants.

❌ Cons of Buying Herb Plants:

✖ More Expensive – A single herb plant costs more than a whole packet of seeds.
✖ Limited Selection – Nurseries may only stock common varieties.
✖ Risk of Pests or Disease – Store-bought plants may carry pests or have been treated with chemicals.

🌿 Best Herbs to Buy as Plants:

✔ Rosemary – Slow-growing and tricky from seed.
✔ Lavender – Difficult to germinate from seed.
✔ Mint – Spreads aggressively, so buying a plant ensures a strong start.
✔ Thyme – Tiny seeds can be tricky; seedlings grow faster.
✔ Oregano – Can take a long time to establish from seed.

Tips for Success with Store-Bought Herbs:

🏡 Acclimate Before Transplanting – Let plants adjust to their new environment before moving them outdoors.
🏺 Choose Healthy Plants – Look for vibrant leaves, strong stems, and no pests.
🌱 Repot if Necessary – Many store-bought herbs are root-bound and benefit from a larger container.
✂ Prune Lightly – Encourage bushy growth by trimming leggy stems.

3. Which Method Is Best for You?

The best method depends on your experience level, budget, and patience.

Factor Starting from Seeds Buying Herb Plants Cost Low (cheap seed packets) Higher (individual plants) Time Takes weeks to months Immediate results Ease Requires care & patience Beginner-friendly Variety Wide range available Limited to what’s in stock Success Rate Can be tricky for beginners More reliable growth

Best Strategy for Continuous Harvests:

🌿 Mix both approaches! Start fast-growing herbs from seed (basil, dill) and buy slow-growing perennials as plants (rosemary, thyme).

Final Thoughts: Choose What Works for You

Whether you love the hands-on process of seed-starting or prefer the instant rewards of buying plants, both methods can lead to a thriving herb garden.

🌱 Starting from seeds is perfect for those who enjoy variety and a budget-friendly option.
🌿 Buying plants is ideal for beginners or those who want herbs ready for immediate use.

No matter which route you take, the key to success is healthy soil, proper watering, and regular harvesting.